Erie, PA Personal Injury Lawyers

When an Injury Wasn’t Just an “Accident”

Most people call what happened to them an accident.

In Pennsylvania, that word doesn’t decide anything.

What matters is whether someone else’s actions—or failure to act—caused you harm. If they did, the law gives you a path to recover compensation. But that path is limited, and it is not always straightforward.

In most cases, you have two years to file a claim under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524. Miss that window, and your case may be over before it begins.

Pennsylvania also follows a modified comparative negligence rule. If you are more than 50% responsible, you cannot recover compensation. If you are less than 51% responsible, your recovery is reduced by your share of fault.

There is also no cap on non-economic damages in most Pennsylvania personal injury cases—meaning pain and suffering damages are not artificially limited under state law.

In car accident cases, your ability to recover for pain and suffering may depend on whether you selected limited tort or full tort coverage, a decision many drivers make without realizing how much it affects their rights later.

These are not small details. They determine whether you have a case—and what that case is worth.

You May Have a Personal Injury Case If

You don’t need to know the law to know something isn’t right.

You may have a case if:

  • You were injured in a car, truck, or motorcycle accident caused by another driver
  • You slipped, tripped, or fell due to unsafe property conditions
  • A medical provider made a mistake that caused harm
  • A defective product failed and injured you
  • You were hurt on a construction site or in a workplace incident involving negligence
  • A dog or animal attack caused serious injury
  • You lost a loved one due to someone else’s actions
  • Your child was injured due to unsafe or poorly maintained conditions

If any of this sounds familiar, the next step is not guessing.

It’s getting clear answers.

What Makes Our Firm Different in Erie

At Purchase, George & Murphey, we don’t approach these cases from the outside.

We’ve handled them from the inside.

Several of our attorneys—including Eric Purchase—previously represented insurance companies. We know how claims are evaluated, how liability is challenged, and how payouts are minimized.

Now we use that knowledge to advocate for injured people.

We are also one of the largest personal injury teams in Erie, with eight attorneys representing clients across:

  • Erie County
  • Crawford County
  • Meadville
  • Western Pennsylvania

That depth matters when a case becomes complex—and when it needs to be taken seriously.

Results That Matter

Every case is different. But results tell you how a firm performs when it matters most.

Examples of outcomes we’ve achieved include:

  • Multi-million dollar settlement for a client seriously injured in a motor vehicle accident resulting in long-term disability
  • Six-figure recovery for a premises liability claim involving unsafe property conditions
  • Significant settlement for a construction site injury involving third-party negligence
  • Confidential resolution in a medical negligence case involving permanent complications

Results don’t guarantee outcomes. But they do reflect preparation, strategy, and a willingness to push cases forward when necessary.

Local Injury Data Matters

Serious injuries are not rare in Pennsylvania—and Erie is no exception.

  • 110,765 reportable crashes occurred statewide in 2024, averaging more than 300 per day
  • 1,127 fatalities were recorded, or roughly one every eight hours
  • Erie County alone saw 2,391 crashes and 36 fatal crashes in a single year

Certain roads in Erie—including State Street, 26th Street, and East Lake Road—have been identified as higher-risk corridors for serious injury accidents.

Workplace injuries are also a growing concern:

  • 185 fatal work injuries occurred in Pennsylvania in 2024, a nearly 10% increase year over year
  • More than 117,000 nonfatal workplace injuries were reported statewide

These are not just numbers. They reflect how often preventable harm actually happens.

Injury Cases We Handle in Erie and Western Pennsylvania

Our personal injury attorneys represent clients in cases involving:

These cases often require more than legal arguments.

They require investigation, expert analysis, and a clear understanding of how the injury changed your life.

What Compensation May Include

A personal injury claim is meant to reflect the full impact of what happened—not just the immediate costs.

Depending on the case, compensation may include:

  • Medical expenses (past and future)
  • Lost income and reduced earning capacity
  • Physical therapy and rehabilitation
  • Long-term care or home modifications
  • Pain and suffering
  • Loss of quality of life

In Pennsylvania, there is no cap on non-economic damages in most personal injury cases, which allows compensation to reflect the real human impact of serious injuries.

What to Expect From the Process

Most people have never been through a personal injury claim before.

You should expect:

  • A clear explanation of your rights and options
  • Regular updates about your case
  • Honest guidance about value and strategy
  • A legal team that prepares your case as if it may go to trial

Most cases resolve outside of court. But preparation is what drives those outcomes.

Talk to an Erie Personal Injury Lawyer

If you have been injured and are not sure what to do next, start with a conversation.

Call (814) 402-8826 for a free consultation.

There is no fee unless we recover compensation for you.

Frequently Asked Questions About Personal Injury Claims in Erie, PA

How do I know if I have a valid personal injury claim?

The best way to know is to have your situation reviewed. Many cases require investigation to determine exactly what happened and who is responsible.

What is a personal injury claim?

A personal injury claim is a legal action seeking compensation for injuries caused by another party’s negligence or reckless conduct.

What if I am partially at fault?

Pennsylvania law allows recovery as long as you are not more than 50% responsible. Your compensation is reduced based on your percentage of fault.

How long do I have to file a claim?

In most cases, you have two years under Pennsylvania law.

Do I have to go to court?

Most cases resolve through settlement, but your legal team should be prepared to go to court if necessary.

Should I speak to the insurance company?

It is usually best to speak with an attorney first. Early statements can affect your claim.

How much is my case worth?

That depends on the severity of the injury, how it affects your life, and the available evidence.

Frequently Asked Question Videos

How long do I have to file a personal injury claim?
How long do I have to file a personal injury claim?

Video Transcript

In Pennsylvania, the general rule is that there is a 2-year statute of limitations to file a personal injury claim. But it’s important to remember that there can be different rules depending upon the circumstances of the case and where the injury happened. Not every client who comes to us was injured in Pennsylvania and every state has their own unique statute of limitations.

So, the general rule, two years. Better rule, if you’ve been injured, call a personal injury lawyer like Purchase George and Murphey and find out what the specific rule is for your case.

Do I have a case if I’m not sure who was at fault?
Do I have a case if I’m not sure who was at fault?

Video Transcript

People sometimes wonder if they have a case even if they don’t know that someone else is at fault. And that’s a good question. What I would encourage you to do is to speak with a personal injury lawyer because there are occasions when people are injured without knowing who’s at fault. Not every injury comes from a red car, blue car accident at a stop sign.

We have people who are injured by products. We have people who are injured in the context of a health care procedure, for example, a surgery, when they don’t know who all is in the room and who is involved in their care. If you have been seriously injured and if you suspect that it may have been because of someone else’s carelessness, talk to a personal injury lawyer.
One of the things that we can do is identify those possible issues. Do the investigation necessary to identify whether someone else was at fault and get the remedy for you that you deserve.

What if I was partially responsible for the accident?
What if I was partially responsible for the accident?

Video Transcript

In our work, it sometimes happens that our client is partially responsible for the accident. It’s rare that the perfect case presents itself. Oftentimes, you have multiple factors that can contribute to an injury or an accident event. Don’t presume that merely because you’re not perfect, you don’t have a right to compensation.

Managing these complexities and understanding how fault ought to be allocated is a big part of what we do. We will be on your side. We will help you make the best of the circumstance.

How much is my case worth?
How much is my case worth?

Video Transcript

You know, I’m often asked, “How much is my case worth?” It’s a perfectly appropriate question. It’s one that I think every client ought to wonder about and ask their lawyer. But the answer is, “Every case is different.” And I won’t know that value until I’ve done the hard work necessary in order to assess those individual components that make up your case.

It can be as complicated as understanding the nuances of the available insurance policies, but more often it’s about understanding the nuances of the impact on your life. And so I understand that a client wants to know that from the beginning of the case. I hope that they will understand it’s not a question that we can answer until we’ve done the hard work necessary to assign a value.

If you’ve suffered personal injury because of the negligence or carelessness of another, the lawyers at Purchase George and Murphey can help. Call us today for a free consultation.

Do I need to go to court?
Do I need to go to court?

Video Transcript

I’m frequently asked by clients whether we have to go to court in order to achieve an outcome for them. And the answer is not always. In almost every case, we make an effort to resolve the client’s claim without filing suit. And a good portion of the time we’re able to do that.

Another important question is, do I have to go to trial? And the answer to that is almost always no. 98, 99% of all cases resolve other than by going to trial. What’s important though is that an insurance company or a hospital system knows that their lawyer is able and willing to go to trial. That risk is what drives settlement value.
If you’ve suffered personal injury because of the negligence or carelessness of another, the lawyers at Purchase George and Murphey can help. Call us today for a free consultation.

How long will my case take?
How long will my case take?

Video Transcript

Everybody wants to know how long their case will take. And the answer is that of course it depends. Every case can be different. I would say on average most cases, if they’re going to resolve without filing suit, will be over within about 6 to 9 months after we know what’s going on with the client’s injury.

Obviously, if the injury isn’t resolved, if we don’t know the full consequences of the injury, then we’re not going to resolve the case. But once we know that, that negotiation process can be resolved within about 6 to 9 months. If it goes to litigation, I tell people that about on average 2 years.

If you’ve suffered personal injury because of the negligence or carelessness of another, the lawyers at Purchase George and Murphey can help. Call us today for a free consultation.

What should I do immediately after an injury?
What should I do immediately after an injury?

Video Transcript

Immediately after an injury, you should attend to making sure that you and your loved ones are safe. Get the medical care that you need. But once you’ve stabilized in that regard, once you’ve taken care of your safety and your health, talk to a lawyer. We can give you the advice, the specific advice you need in order to preserve evidence and take advantage of the opportunities and resources that are available to help you.

If you’ve suffered personal injury because of the negligence or carelessness of another, the lawyers of Purchase George and Murphey can help. Call us today for a free consultation.

Will insurance cover my medical bills?
Will insurance cover my medical bills?

Video Transcript

Insurance will be available to help clients in the short term, but it’s important to understand what insurance is available. Very often we look at two primary resources in the short term. In auto cases, there’s first-party medical benefits that are available to cover medical bills in the short term. And when those are exhausted, the second resource is health insurance.

What isn’t available in the short term is the liability insurance that applies to the third party who caused the accident. That won’t be achieved. That won’t be accessed until the very end of the case. If you suffered personal injury because of the negligence or carelessness of another, the lawyers at Purchase George and Murphey can help. Call us today for a free consultation.

How are personal injury lawyers paid?
How are personal injury lawyers paid?

Video Transcript

The way personal injury lawyers are paid is generally through a contingent fee agreement. This is what you’ve heard about before. We don’t get paid unless we get money for you. It’s a valuable fee system to a client because it allows the client to not have to lay out cash during the process, which can be hugely valuable to people who’ve just been injured because they sometimes aren’t working.

They sometimes are overwhelmed with their own bills and so we don’t get paid until we have won or obtained a recovery for the client and then we get a percentage of it. It’s possible for lawyers to extend an offer of representation on an hourly basis where you pay as you go. Not necessarily a bad thing, but I’d be cautious about an arrangement like that because if the lawyer doesn’t express a willingness to take a risk with you, to share that risk with you, you ought to think twice about their own assessment of the value of your case. If you’ve suffered personal injury because of the negligence or carelessness of another, the lawyers at Purchase George and Murphey can help. Call us today for a free consultation.

What if the insurance company already contacted me?
What if the insurance company already contacted me?

Video Transcript

You know, it happens sometimes that clients come to us and by the time they arrive in our office, they’ve already been contacted by one or more insurance companies. And what I would tell people when they’re in those circumstances is this. If it is your insurance company calling you, you should talk to them.

You should share information with them. That’s important because you have a contractual obligation to do so. And that’s what allows you to access the benefits of your own insurance policy. However, if it is the other insurance company, if it is the insurance company for the fellow who was involved in the accident with you and caused your injury, you should not speak with them.

There is no advantage to you to be gained and frankly there’s substantial risk because you aren’t prepared and very often they aren’t acting in your best interest. So know who’s calling you. If it’s your insurance company, feel free to share information with them. If it is the other insurance company, please do not talk to a lawyer first.

If you’ve suffered personal injury because of the negligence or carelessness of another, the lawyers at Purchase George and Murphey can help. Call us today for a free consultation.

Load More

THE REALITY

An Injury Changes

More Than One Moment

Millions injured
each year

Many require long-term care

Families often impacted financially

WHAT CAUSES INJURY

Most Injuries Start With a
Preventable Mistake

Negligence is a leading cause

Unsafe conditions drive many incidents

Failure to follow basic safety rules

HUMAN IMPACT

The Effects Go

Beyond the Physical

Emotional trauma is common

Daily life is often disrupted

Recovery can take months or years