SSD Appeals Process in Erie, Pennsylvania
PA Social Security Disability Appeals Lawyers Help Clients in Erie County, Crawford County, and Across Western Pennsylvania
Because the Social Security Administration (SSA) denies about two-thirds of initial claims for disability benefits, appeals of negative decisions are common. Pennsylvania has streamlined the appeals process somewhat so that disabled workers appealing a negative decision do not have to wait even longer. However, just because the state eliminated a step does not mean that the process is uncomplicated and fast. Most people who appeal their SSD denials hire lawyers to be their advocates during the appeals process.
At the Erie, PA law firm of Purchase, George & Murphey, P.C. our injury lawyers help clients file appeals after the SSA denies an initial Social Security Disability claim. Because we know the process so well, we are in a good position to help clients improve their chances of obtaining a favorable outcome and avoid mistakes that could derail their appeals.
The SSD Appeals Process in Pennsylvania
Fortunately, Pennsylvania has streamlined the SSD appeals process, eliminating the “request for reconsideration” step that requires Social Security staff to review the paper file. One reason for this elimination, which has also occurred in other states, is that the reconsideration process did not reverse many negative decisions. The remaining appeals process consists of:
Hearing before an administrative law judge (ALJ): Pennsylvania has eight hearing offices where appellants and their lawyers can appear to argue their cases for SSD benefits. Unfortunately, obtaining a hearing date can take a lot of time, often in excess of one year. More than 55 percent of disability hearings in Pennsylvania result in an award of SSD benefits. The hearing requires you to appear in person before the ALJ, who will ask you questions about the evidence of disability and your work history. You can bring witnesses to the hearing who can testify to your inability to work because of your impairment.
Petition the Appeals Council: If you wish to pursue your SSD appeal further, you have 60 days to file an appeal with the Social Security Disability Appeals Council. This body reviews cases after determining that the previous level handled the case incorrectly. Few decisions are overturned at the Appeals Council stage.
File a federal lawsuit: If the Appeals Council declines to take your case or decides unfavorably, the final step of the appeals process is to file a lawsuit in federal court.
Your best chance of having an initial decision overturned is at the ALJ hearing level. Pennsylvania ALJs approve around 40 percent of appeals they hear, which is slightly lower than the national average. Our lawyers will be with you every step of the way, however long it takes.
Contact Our Erie Attorneys About an SSD Appeal in Pennsylvania
To discuss filing a SSD appeal, call our knowledgeable lawyers at Purchase, George & Murphey, P.C. in Erie, PA. You may also use our website’s contact form. We help people file Social Security Disability appeals at all levels of the process.
Notable Results
Purchase, George & Murphey, P.C. publishes the following results.
$1.25 Million verdict · $700,000 settlement
Read more about these results
- $1.25 million verdict: McKean County car accident. Read the source account.
- $700,000 settlement: Motorcycle fatality; the underinsured motorist carrier paid the policy limits. Read the source account.
- $325,000 settlement: Truck driver’s injury claim grown from an initial offer of zero in six months. Read the source account.
- $260,000 evaluation: Rear-end accident underinsured motorist claim. Read the source account.
- $200,000 settlement: Pennsylvania premises liability case. Read the source account.
- $185,000 settlement: Accident settlement for a C5-C6 herniation requiring vertebral fusion. Read the source account.
Read the firm’s published results
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Each case is different and must be evaluated on its own facts.
What Our Clients Say
These excerpts describe experiences with the firm. They are not identified as cases in this practice area and do not predict another outcome.
“Great firm to work with the legal teams are caring, considerate, and are always there for you when you have a question. I wouldn’t use anyone else.”
— Stephen · Read the full Google review
“From the moment I contacted Attorney Tim George, he acted quickly and followed up with me after hours. He always kept me informed. Tim George is incredibly compassionate and empathetic. Tim is a strong negotiator and stands strong for his clients facing serious criminal charges.”
— Tracy · Read the full Google review
Awards & Recognition
- AV Preeminent® — Martindale-Hubbell’s highest peer review rating for ethics and legal ability.
- Pennsylvania Super Lawyers — all three firm principals named to the list; Craig Murphey has been selected every year since 2011 and Eric Purchase every year since 2013.
- The Best Lawyers in America® — Craig Murphey listed since 2012 and named “Lawyer of the Year” for the Pittsburgh region in Personal Injury–Defense (2017) and Insurance Law (2019 and 2023); Tim Riley listed since 2008.
- Avvo — 10.0 “Superb” rating and Client’s Choice Awards for criminal defense and DUI defense.
- The National Trial Lawyers — Top 100 Trial Lawyers.